CosmeticRanker
Menu

Review

NYX Matte Setting Spray Review

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Makeup Setting Spray is a matte finishing mist designed to help makeup stay in place while reducing visible shine. It stands out for strong value, a lightweight feel and broad customer approval, though reviews are more mixed for very oily skin and the nozzle is not consistently praised.
Expert reviewed
82
Overall score
Data-driven scoring Expert reviewed Updated analysis

Why we ranked it highly

This product is a liquid makeup setting spray designed as the final step in a face makeup routine. According to the listing, it is intended to help lock in foundation, eyeshadow and powder while supporting a matte, shine-free finish for up to 16 hours. The bottle format and simple spray application make it a straightforward option for everyday use, and the formula is described as lightweight and comfortable. The supplied review and score data suggest it is most appealing to shoppers who want an affordable, widely used finishing spray from a recognized makeup brand. Customer feedback is especially positive around wear support, comfort and price, with many users saying it helps their makeup look fresher for longer. The main caveats are mixed performance on very oily skin and repeated complaints about inconsistent nozzle performance and occasional packaging issues.
90-day review Expert reviewed User feedback Data scoring

Key specs

Features & Specs

Item Form
Liquid
Product Benefits
16HR Formula
Skin Tone
All
Skin Type
All
Container Type
Bottle
Coverage
Sheer

Item details

Brand Name
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP
Country as Labeled
Andorra
Package Type Name
Bottle
Global Trade Identification Number
00800897813710
UPC
800897813710
Manufacturer
NYX Cosmetics USA, Inc.
Manufacturer Part Number
800897813710
Model Number
K4099405
Included Components
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Makeup Setting Spray, Matte Setting Spray for 16HR Make Up Wear
Item Type Name
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Makeup Setting Spray, Matte Setting Spray for 16HR Make Up Wear

Item details

Brand Name
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP
Country as Labeled
Andorra
Package Type Name
Bottle
Global Trade Identification Number
00800897813710
UPC
800897813710
Manufacturer
NYX Cosmetics USA, Inc.
Manufacturer Part Number
800897813710
Model Number
K4099405
Included Components
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Makeup Setting Spray, Matte Setting Spray for 16HR Make Up Wear
Item Type Name
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Makeup Setting Spray, Matte Setting Spray for 16HR Make Up Wear

Features & Specs

Item Form
Liquid
Product Benefits
16HR Formula
Skin Tone
All
Skin Type
All
Container Type
Bottle
Coverage
Sheer

Product details

Is Discontinued By Manufacturer
No
Product Dimensions
1.4 x 1.4 x 4.8 inches; 0.28 ounces
Item model number
K4099405
Department
Unisex-Adult
UPC
800897813710
Manufacturer
NYX Cosmetics USA, Inc.

Scores breakdown

84 /100

Effectiveness

82 /100

Beauty results

68 /100

Skin compatibility

85 /100

Finish quality

80 /100

Longevity

70 /100

Ingredient quality

72 /100

Safety

85 /100

Comfort

Strengths

  • Strong value score supported by a modest price and frequent reviewer praise for affordability.
  • Matte finish is a clear strength, with many users describing a fresh, shine-reduced look after application.
  • Good wear support for a setting spray, with positive feedback on helping makeup stay in place through long days.
  • Lightweight feel and quick-drying texture improve day-to-day comfort.
  • Large review volume and a 4.5/5 average suggest broad customer satisfaction.
  • Works across different makeup steps including foundation, eyeshadow and powder according to the product description.
  • Cruelty-free positioning is explicitly provided by the brand and supported by PETA acknowledgement in the listing.

Limitations

  • Results appear mixed for very oily skin, with some reviewers saying the mattifying effect was limited.
  • Nozzle performance is inconsistent in some reviews, which may affect spray distribution.
  • Packaging concerns include reports of missing caps and a lack of a tamper-style safety seal.
  • The 16-hour wear claim is only partly supported by user feedback and not consistently confirmed in reviews.
  • Ingredient detail is not provided in the supplied data, which limits ingredient-level assessment.
  • Personalization is limited because this is a single matte-finish format rather than a highly customizable product.
  • Build quality is not a standout area, with weak scoring tied mainly to the spray mechanism rather than the formula itself.

Ideal user profiles

  • Makeup wearers looking for an affordable matte setting spray for everyday use.
  • Users who want a lightweight finishing mist that dries quickly and feels comfortable on skin.
  • Buyers who value broad customer approval and a well-established makeup brand.
  • People wanting a setting spray to help foundation and powder look fresher across work or school days.
  • Shoppers specifically looking for a cruelty-free setting spray option.

Use cases

  • Setting a full-face makeup look before a long work day.
  • Reducing visible shine in matte makeup routines.
  • Helping foundation, powder and eye makeup hold up in warm conditions.
  • Finishing everyday makeup with a lightweight mist.
  • Touchpoint support for events where transfer reduction matters.
  • Budget-conscious beauty routines that still prioritize wear time.

Fit and positioning

Who this works for

Category positioning

This is primarily a makeup product rather than skincare. Its role is to sit at the end of a makeup routine, helping set complexion and eye products while supporting a more matte overall look. Within the setting spray category, it positions itself as an accessible, long-wear finishing mist focused on shine reduction, wear support and comfort rather than coverage or complexion correction.

Best for

This setting spray is best suited to users who want an affordable matte finishing mist for everyday makeup wear. The strongest indicators are its high value score, strong finish quality score, and large volume of positive customer feedback about keeping makeup looking fresh across work days, classes and warm conditions. It also suits buyers who prefer lightweight products that dry quickly and do not feel sticky.

Not best for

It may be less suitable for people with very oily skin who need stronger shine control, since review feedback is divided in that area. It is also not the best fit for buyers who are highly sensitive to packaging quality, as some reviews mention missing caps, inconsistent spray output and a lack of a more secure tamper-style seal. Those expecting clearly proven 16-hour wear may also want to keep expectations moderate.

Beauty results

The visible result is a more matte, freshly finished makeup look rather than extra coverage or glow. Review feedback often points to a smoother, more seamless appearance after drying, with less obvious shine and reduced smearing. For many users, it helps makeup look more polished for longer, though the mattifying effect is not equally convincing for every oily-skin wearer.

Performance analysis

How it performs in practice

Each scoring dimension is separated into a compact card so the strengths and tradeoffs are easier to compare without reading one long block.

Effectiveness analysis

With an effectiveness score of 84 , this setting spray performs well in its main role of helping makeup stay in place. The product description focuses on extending wear and resisting colour fade, and many reviews align with that general purpose, with users reporting that makeup stays put through work days, teaching shifts and warm weather. The main performance concern is consistency across skin types. While many buyers find it dependable, some reviewers with very oily skin say it did not noticeably improve wear or oil control. Overall, the data supports strong but not universal performance.

Beauty results

The beauty result score of 82 suggests a solid cosmetic payoff. This product’s main visual effect is a smoother, more matte finish that helps makeup look freshly applied for longer. Reviews describing a seamless dry-down and reduced transfer support that outcome. The result looks strongest for users seeking a shine-controlled finish rather than a radiant or skin-like glow.

Skin compatibility

The skin compatibility score of 68 points to acceptable but uneven skin-type suitability. The listing states it is for all skin types, and some reviews mention that it felt light, did not leave residue and did not trigger obvious skin issues. However, feedback is mixed for oily skin, with several users saying the mattifying effect faded quickly or was not strong enough. Based on the supplied data, compatibility appears better in terms of comfort than oil-control consistency.

Finish quality

Finish is one of the stronger parts of this product, reflected in a finish quality score of 85 . The intended result is clearly matte, and many users describe a fresh, shine-reduced look that dries down smoothly. Positive comments about a seamless finish and a non-sticky feel strengthen that profile. The main limitation is that the finish does not appear equally mattifying for every oily-skin user.

How it compares

Within the setting spray category, this product appears stronger than average on value, finish and broad customer approval. It seems especially competitive for buyers who want a matte result without paying premium prices, and review sentiment suggests many users see it as a practical alternative to more expensive sprays. Compared with stronger category leaders, its weaker points are less about the formula itself and more about packaging execution and consistency across oily skin types. That means it compares well as an accessible daily-use option, but less well as a precision-packaged or highly specialized oil-control spray.

Ranking summary

With an overall score of 82 , this product ranks as a strong option in the setting spray category rather than an untouchable top-tier performer. Its best areas are value, customer satisfaction, finish quality, comfort and effectiveness, which together create a convincing everyday makeup product profile. The very large review count and 4.5/5 average also strengthen its standing. It places slightly lower than the very best-in-class options because of weaker packaging quality, low build quality related to nozzle performance, and mixed results on very oily skin. In short, it ranks well because the formula and finish are stronger than the delivery system.

Buying advice

This product is worth considering if you want an affordable matte setting spray from a widely used makeup brand and you value a lightweight, quick-drying finish. It makes the most sense for everyday makeup wearers who want help extending wear across work, school or warm days without spending heavily. Be more cautious if you have very oily skin and need strong shine control, since user feedback is mixed in that area. Before buying, check your tolerance for bottle-style mists, inspect packaging on arrival, and keep expectations realistic around the 16-hour claim, which appears directionally supported rather than consistently proven.
82
Overall score

Final verdict

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Matte Setting Spray is a strong category option for shoppers who want a budget-friendly finishing mist with a reliable matte look and generally good wear support. Its main strength is the combination of finish quality, comfort and value, backed by a very large volume of positive reviews. Its main limitation is inconsistency: the spray nozzle is not always dependable, and users with very oily skin may not get the level of mattifying performance they want. Overall, it is a practical, broadly appealing setting spray that performs well for many users, even if it is not the most polished formula-and-packaging package in the category.
Back to review

Key topics

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Makeup Setting Spray review, NYX matte setting spray, best matte setting spray, long lasting makeup setting spray, vegan setting spray review, affordable makeup setting spray, makeup finishing spray matte, NYX setting spray 16HR, cruelty free setting spray

Frequently asked questions

Is NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Makeup Setting Spray good for keeping makeup in place?
Based on the supplied scores and review data, it performs well for its core purpose. It has an effectiveness score of 84, and many reviewers say it helps makeup stay fresh-looking through long days. Results are positive overall, though not every user found the hold equally strong.
Does this NYX setting spray give a matte finish?
Yes, the product is positioned as a matte setting spray, and that is one of its stronger areas. Its finish quality score is 85, and multiple reviews mention a smooth, less shiny look after application. That said, some users with very oily skin did not find the mattifying effect strong enough.
Is NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Makeup Setting Spray suitable for oily skin?
The listing says it is for all skin types, but the review data shows mixed results for oily skin. Some users felt it helped control shine, while others with very oily skin said their makeup still broke down after a few hours. The skin compatibility score of 68 reflects that uneven experience.
How long does NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Makeup Setting Spray last?
The brand describes it as a 16-hour formula, and the longevity score is 80, which indicates solid wear overall. Many buyers report all-day support, especially for work or event wear. However, not every review confirms the full claimed duration, so wear time appears to vary by user and skin type.
Is this setting spray easy to apply?
In general, yes. It has an ease of use score of 82 and is described as lightweight and quick drying. Reviews often mention that it feels simple to use as a final makeup step, but some buyers report an inconsistent nozzle that can affect how evenly the mist comes out.
What are the main drawbacks of NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Makeup Setting Spray?
The main limitations are inconsistent spray performance, packaging complaints, and mixed results for very oily skin. A few buyers mention missing caps or wanting a better safety seal, while others say the formula did not keep them matte for as long as expected. These are the main factors holding the product back.
Does NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Makeup Setting Spray offer good value?
Yes, value is one of its strongest areas. It has a value score of 88, and several reviewers say it performs well relative to its price, with some comparing it favorably to more expensive setting sprays. It appears especially appealing to shoppers looking for affordable everyday makeup support.
Is the formula comfortable to wear?
Comfort appears to be a strong point. The comfort score is 85, and review feedback often describes the spray as lightweight, quick drying, and non-sticky. Some users also mention that it feels fresh on the skin, though comfort alone does not guarantee the same level of oil control for everyone.

Related Guides & Rankings

Mario Badescu Facial Spray Review: Rose Water F... Mario Badescu Facial Spray Review: Rose Water F... e.l.f. Makeup Mist & Set Review: Long-Lasting S... e.l.f. Makeup Mist & Set Review: Long-Lasting S... Sally's Organics Amber Glass Spray Bottles Review Sally's Organics Amber Glass Spray Bottles Review