CosmeticRanker
Menu

Review

e.l.f. Makeup Mist & Set Review

e.l.f. Makeup Mist & Set is a lightweight makeup setting spray designed to help hold face and eye makeup in place while controlling shine. It stands out for strong wear time, broad buyer approval, and very accessible pricing. Its main drawbacks are mixed scent feedback and reports from some users that the spray can feel wetter than expected.
Expert reviewed
88
Overall score
Data-driven scoring Expert reviewed Updated analysis

Why we ranked it highly

e.l.f. Makeup Mist & Set is a spray-format setting product designed to be used after makeup application to help extend wear and refresh the finished look. In the provided product information, it is positioned as a lightweight, all-day setting spray that can support foundation, concealer, blush and eye makeup while also helping manage excess shine. The formula is described as containing aloe, green tea, cucumber, vitamins, and other hydrating or soothing ingredients, and it is marketed for all skin types. In practical routine terms, this is aimed at makeup users who want a quick final step that is simple, low-cost and easy to reapply during the day. Review sentiment suggests it is especially popular with oily-skin users looking for a more matte-looking finish, though not every buyer agrees on the mist quality or scent.
90-day review Expert reviewed User feedback Data scoring

Key specs

Features & Specs

Item Form
Spray
Product Benefits
Hydrating, Soothing
Skin Tone
All
Skin Type
All
Container Type
Bottle
Coverage
light

Item details

Brand Name
e.l.f.
Package Type Name
Box
Global Trade Identification Number
00609332850255
UPC
609332850255
Manufacturer
e.l.f. Cosmetics
Manufacturer Part Number
B85025-2
Model Number
85025

Product details

Is Discontinued By Manufacturer
No
Product Dimensions
1.65 x 1.65 x 5.91 inches; 5.28 ounces
Item model number
85025
UPC
609332850255
Manufacturer
e.l.f. Cosmetics

Scores breakdown

90 /100

Effectiveness

88 /100

Beauty results

84 /100

Skin compatibility

4 /100

Hair compatibility

2 /100

Shade range

87 /100

Finish quality

91 /100

Longevity

78 /100

Ingredient quality

Strengths

  • Strong overall wear performance, supported by a 91 longevity score and repeated feedback that makeup stays in place for hours.
  • Good value for money, with a 95 value score and a low listed price relative to the review volume and buyer satisfaction.
  • Works well for everyday makeup setting, especially for users looking to reduce shine and maintain a more matte-looking finish.
  • Large review base with high customer approval, including a 4.5/5 star average from 39,237 reviews.
  • Lightweight spray format is easy to add at the end of a makeup routine or for touch-ups during the day.
  • Includes hydrating and soothing ingredients such as aloe, green tea, cucumber, and vitamins, according to the product description.
  • Vegan and cruelty-free positioning is clearly stated, with Leaping Bunny and PETA certification mentioned.

Limitations

  • Scent appears inconsistent in buyer feedback, with some users finding it pleasant and others describing it less favourably.
  • Some customers report the spray feels wetter than expected rather than delivering a very fine mist.
  • Ingredient quality is solid but not standout at 78, with limited detailed transparency beyond highlighted ingredients.
  • Packaging quality is adequate rather than exceptional, reflected in a 78 score and at least one delivery-related packaging complaint.
  • Personalization is limited because this is a single-format setting spray without shade or finish variants clearly outlined here.
  • Claims around hydration and soothing are supported mainly by ingredient listing and user experience rather than stronger testing evidence in the provided data.

Ideal user profiles

  • People with oily or combination skin who want better makeup hold and less visible shine through the day.
  • Budget-conscious makeup users looking for an affordable everyday setting spray.
  • Students, commuters, or on-the-go users who want quick touch-ups in a simple spray format.
  • Buyers who prefer vegan and cruelty-free makeup products.
  • Anyone wanting a lightweight finishing step after foundation, concealer, blush, or eye makeup.

Use cases

  • Setting foundation and concealer at the end of a daily makeup routine.
  • Reducing midday shine without fully redoing makeup.
  • Refreshing makeup during hot or humid days.
  • Helping eye makeup stay in place for longer wear.
  • Spraying onto a brush or sponge before application for potentially improved hold.
  • Low-cost makeup setting for school, work, or everyday errands.

Fit and positioning

Who this works for

Category positioning

This product sits firmly in the makeup category, specifically within finishing products used to set and refresh makeup. Its main role is not coverage or colour, but helping the makeup already applied look more stable and less shiny through the day. Within a routine, it fits as a final step after complexion and eye products, or as a light touch-up spray later on. Based on the supplied data, it leans toward practical everyday wear support rather than premium packaging or highly specialized customization.

Best for

e.l.f. Makeup Mist & Set appears best for everyday makeup users who want affordable, reliable hold without adding a heavy layer to the skin. It is particularly well suited to oily or combination skin users seeking a smoother, more matte-looking finish, as that benefit appears repeatedly in both the product details and customer feedback. It also makes sense for shoppers who value vegan and cruelty-free beauty products.

Not best for

This setting spray may be less suitable for buyers who are highly sensitive to fragrance or very particular about an ultra-fine mist, since scent feedback is mixed and some users say the spray feels wetter than expected. It is also not the most personalized option, as there is no shade choice and limited finish variation in the provided data. Shoppers wanting premium packaging or more detailed ingredient transparency may expect more than this product offers.

Beauty results

The visible result appears to be makeup that looks fresher, more set, and less shiny over time. Buyer feedback points to a smooth matte-leaning finish for many users, while some also describe a lightly refreshed or slightly dewy effect depending on skin type and application. Overall, the product seems to improve the finished makeup look more through longevity and shine control than through dramatic texture or coverage changes.

Performance analysis

How it performs in practice

Each scoring dimension is separated into a compact card so the strengths and tradeoffs are easier to compare without reading one long block.

Effectiveness analysis

With an effectiveness score of 90, this setting spray performs strongly for its core purpose: helping makeup stay in place while supporting a fresher-looking finish. The product details specifically mention hold for foundation, concealer, blush and eye makeup, and customer feedback broadly aligns with that positioning. Reviews from oily-skin users are especially positive, often highlighting better shine control and less makeup breakdown through long days or humid conditions. The main performance caveat is consistency of spray feel, since some buyers report that it can land a little wetter than expected rather than as a very fine mist.

Beauty results

The beauty result score of 88 suggests a strong visible payoff for a low-cost setting spray. Most of the evidence points to a smoother, more set makeup appearance with less obvious shine, which is particularly useful for oily skin or long wear days. Some reviews also mention a refreshed or lightly hydrated look, so the finish does not read exactly the same for every user. Overall, the final effect seems polished and practical rather than transformative.

Skin compatibility

The skin compatibility score of 84 indicates generally good versatility for a makeup setting spray. It is marketed for all skin types and includes ingredients described as hydrating and soothing, while review feedback includes positive reactions from oily and combination skin users. Still, compatibility is not perfect: scent concerns and comments about a wetter spray feel may matter more to users who are reactive to fragrance or who dislike products that sit noticeably on the skin before drying.

Finish quality

At 87 for finish quality, this product scores well for how it leaves makeup looking once applied. The main finish profile in the supplied data is matte to soft-matte, with repeated mention of shine control and a smoother-looking complexion. A smaller number of users describe a more refreshed or slightly dewy effect, which suggests the finish can vary somewhat by skin type and product layering. The main drawback is that a wetter spray pattern may affect how refined the finish feels for some buyers.

How it compares

Within its category, this product appears stronger than average for value, wear time and broad customer approval. It stands out less for premium formula sophistication or packaging polish, but it competes well on practical daily performance. Compared with many setting sprays, it seems especially appealing for buyers who want shine control and longer wear without spending much. Its review profile also suggests it resonates particularly well with oily-skin users. Where it appears less competitive is in refinement details such as scent consistency and mist experience, which can matter more to shoppers who are very selective about finish feel and spray quality.

Ranking summary

With an overall score of 88, e.l.f. Makeup Mist & Set ranks as a strong option in the setting spray category, particularly for shoppers prioritizing longevity, value and everyday usability. Its best sub-scores include value at 95, customer satisfaction at 93, longevity at 91 and effectiveness at 90, which together support its reputation as a practical, budget-friendly makeup fixer. It is not quite a top-tier all-rounder in every metric, because scent, packaging refinement and personalization are less impressive. Still, the balance of strong hold, matte-leaning finish and broad buyer approval explains why it places well within its category.

Buying advice

This spray is worth considering if you want an affordable setting product that can help makeup last longer and look less shiny through the day. It is especially relevant for oily or combination skin users, students, commuters and anyone building a practical low-cost makeup routine. Before buying, think about whether you are comfortable with some fragrance and whether you strongly prefer an ultra-fine mist, since those are the main weak points in the provided data. If you are very sensitive to scented products or dislike sprays that can feel slightly wet before drying, read reviews carefully and patch test if needed.
88
Overall score

Final verdict

e.l.f. Makeup Mist & Set is a strong budget-friendly option in the makeup setting spray category. Its main strength is reliable everyday performance, particularly for wear time, shine control and overall value, all backed by a large volume of positive customer feedback. Its main limitation is that the experience is not perfectly refined: scent opinions are mixed, and some users find the spray wetter than ideal. Even with those drawbacks, the scoring profile suggests this is a dependable, practical choice for many makeup users, especially those who want longer-lasting results without paying premium prices.
Back to review

Key topics

e.l.f. Makeup Mist & Set review, e.l.f. setting spray, best drugstore setting spray, matte setting spray for oily skin, hydrating makeup setting spray, long lasting makeup spray, vegan cruelty free setting spray, makeup mist and set review

Frequently asked questions

Is e.l.f. Makeup Mist & Set good for keeping makeup in place?
Based on the provided scores and review data, it performs well for its main purpose. It has a 90 effectiveness score and a 91 longevity score, and many buyers say it helps foundation, concealer and eye makeup stay in place for hours. Results still vary by skin type, climate and the rest of the routine.
Is e.l.f. Makeup Mist & Set suitable for oily skin?
It appears especially relevant for oily skin users because the product is positioned for shine control and several reviews specifically praise its matte-looking finish on oily or combination skin. That said, it is marketed for all skin types, so buyers who prefer a more dewy finish may want to check whether the matte effect suits their routine.
Does e.l.f. Makeup Mist & Set feel hydrating or matte?
The product sits between both ideas in the supplied data. The brand description highlights hydrating and soothing ingredients, while customer feedback often mentions shine control and a matte-looking finish. Some users also describe a refreshed or lightly hydrated feel, so the result may depend on skin type and how heavily it is applied.
Does the spray have a fine mist?
Feedback is mixed. Some reviewers describe the mist as soft, fine and even, while the aggregated review summary notes that a portion of customers felt it made the face feel wet rather than lightly misted. If you are very particular about atomizer quality, this is one of the main points to consider before buying.
How strong is the scent of e.l.f. Makeup Mist & Set?
Scent is a weaker area than most of the product's other performance metrics, with a scent score of 66. Some customers say it smells pleasant and light, while others describe the scent less positively. If fragrance is a regular concern for you, this is worth keeping in mind.
Is e.l.f. Makeup Mist & Set good value for money?
Yes, value looks like one of its clearest strengths. It has a 95 value score, a low listed price, and many reviews describe performance that buyers felt exceeded expectations for the cost. It appears especially appealing for shoppers who want a low-cost setting spray without giving up everyday usability.
Are the product claims well supported?
The hold and shine-control claims are reasonably well supported by the available data, including strong scores, a large review count and repeated user feedback. Hydrating and soothing claims are more modestly supported through ingredient mentions and customer impressions rather than stronger testing evidence in the provided information.
Who is e.l.f. Makeup Mist & Set best for?
It looks best suited to everyday makeup wearers who want longer wear, easier touch-ups and better shine control at a budget-friendly price. It is also a practical option for buyers who specifically prefer vegan and cruelty-free products. Those who dislike any noticeable scent or wetter sprays may be less enthusiastic.

Related Guides & Rankings

Sally's Organics Amber Glass Spray Bottles Review Sally's Organics Amber Glass Spray Bottles Review