CosmeticRanker
Menu

Review

Maybelline Lifter Gloss Gummy Bear Review: Hydrating Lip Gloss

Maybelline New York Lifter Gloss in Gummy Bear is a liquid lip gloss with a sheer, light warm-pink tint and high-gloss finish. It is positioned for comfortable, hydrated-looking lips and quick application with an XL wand. Its main limitation is wear time: the shine may require touch-ups, and the fuller-looking effect appears subtle.
Expert reviewed
87
Overall score
Data-driven scoring Expert reviewed Updated analysis

Why we ranked it highly

Maybelline New York Lifter Gloss in shade 21 Gummy Bear is a liquid lip makeup product designed to add sheer light-pink colour and a high-gloss finish. The listing identifies hyaluronic acid as a special ingredient and describes the formula as hydrating, while its main cosmetic goal is a smoother-looking lip surface and fuller-looking contour. Gummy Bear has a warm undertone, light shade depth, and sheer intensity, making it a more understated option than a full-coverage lipstick. The oversized wand is intended to make application fast and even. With a listed price of $9.98, 0.18-ounce size, 4.5/5 average rating, and 56,066 reviews, it is a broadly tried option for adults seeking a comfortable, glossy lip look. Available evidence supports shine and ease of use more strongly than long wear or noticeable plumping.
90-day review Expert reviewed User feedback Data scoring

Key specs

Features & Specs

Item Form
Liquid
Finish Types
High-Glossy
Product Benefits
Hydrating, Plumping
Special Ingredients
Hyaluronic Acid
Specialty
Natural
Skin Tone
All
Lip Color Type
Lip Gloss
Lip Color Undertone
Warm
Lip Color Shade Depth
Light
Lip Color Intensity
Sheer
Skin Type
All, Combination
Coverage
Full,Sheer

Item details

Brand Name
MAYBELLINE
Color
21 GUMMY BEAR
Age Range Description
Adult
Target Audience
Women
Manufacturer
Maybelline New York
UPC
041554085372
Global Trade Identification Number
00041554085372
Manufacturer Part Number
0041554085372
Model Number
0041554085372
Item Type Name
Lip Makeup

Features & Specs

Item Form
Liquid
Finish Types
High-Glossy
Product Benefits
Hydrating, Plumping
Special Ingredients
Hyaluronic Acid
Specialty
Natural
Skin Tone
All
Lip Color Type
Lip Gloss
Lip Color Undertone
Warm
Lip Color Shade Depth
Light
Lip Color Intensity
Sheer
Skin Type
All, Combination
Coverage
Full,Sheer

Item details

Brand Name
MAYBELLINE
Color
21 GUMMY BEAR
Age Range Description
Adult
Target Audience
Women
Manufacturer
Maybelline New York
UPC
041554085372
Global Trade Identification Number
00041554085372
Manufacturer Part Number
0041554085372
Model Number
0041554085372
Item Type Name
Lip Makeup

Product details

Product Dimensions
3.74 x 0.9 x 3.74 inches; 0.18 ounces
Item model number
0041554085372
UPC
041554085372
Manufacturer
Maybelline New York

Scores breakdown

85 /100

Effectiveness

88 /100

Beauty results

84 /100

Skin compatibility

75 /100

Hair compatibility

86 /100

Shade range

92 /100

Finish quality

67 /100

Longevity

82 /100

Ingredient quality

Strengths

  • High-gloss finish quality scored 92/100, supporting a polished, light-reflective lip look.
  • XL wand and liquid format earned strong application and ease-of-use scores of 91/100 and 93/100.
  • Customer feedback frequently praises the smooth, comfortable texture and low-stickiness feel.
  • Gummy Bear is a sheer, light warm-pink option suited to understated colour.
  • The 20-shade range and 85/100 personalization score offer options beyond this individual shade.
  • High buyer confidence is reflected in a 4.5/5 average from 56,066 reviews and a 91/100 satisfaction score.

Limitations

  • Longevity scored 67/100; several reviews indicate that gloss may need reapplication during the day.
  • The fuller-looking lip effect appears subtle and is not consistently experienced by reviewers.
  • Gummy Bear has sheer, light colour intensity, so it is not the best match for buyers seeking opaque coverage.
  • Scent and taste feedback is mixed, with a minority of users noting a coconut, vanilla, or chocolate-like impression.
  • The ingredient list was not provided, limiting assessment beyond the stated hyaluronic acid ingredient.
  • One review felt the large-looking package contained less product than expected; the listed net weight is 0.18 ounces.

Ideal user profiles

  • Adults seeking a sheer light-pink gloss for everyday makeup.
  • Gloss users who prioritize high shine and a smooth, less sticky-feeling texture.
  • Buyers who want a quick one-swipe lip product with an oversized wand.
  • People who prefer a subtle, hydrated-looking finish over intense lip colour.
  • Shoppers looking for a widely reviewed drugstore lip gloss under $10 at the listed price.

Use cases

  • Adding sheer pink shine to a minimal everyday makeup look.
  • Layering over lip liner or a drier lipstick for extra gloss.
  • Quick lip touch-ups between activities.
  • Creating a polished high-shine finish for daytime or evening makeup.
  • Keeping in a makeup bag for simple, wand-based application.

Fit and positioning

Who this works for

Category positioning

This is primarily a makeup product: a tinted lip gloss that sits between clear gloss and sheer lip colour. Its role in a routine is to provide shine, a light wash of pink, and a smoother-looking finish with minimal application effort. It can be worn alone for a natural-looking lip or layered over lip liner or lipstick. Compared with more opaque lip products, Gummy Bear is positioned around finish, comfort, and a hydrated appearance rather than intense pigment or all-day wear.

Best for

Maybelline Lifter Gloss Gummy Bear is best for people who want a sheer, easy-to-wear pink gloss with pronounced shine. The 92/100 finish score, 90/100 comfort score, and 93/100 ease-of-use score make it particularly suitable for quick everyday makeup and for those who do not enjoy a heavily sticky gloss texture. It also suits buyers who appreciate a large shade range but prefer this soft, warm-leaning light-pink option.

Not best for

This gloss is less suitable for shoppers who want opaque colour, highly precise pigment, or a transfer-resistant lip product that lasts through the day. The 67/100 longevity score and mixed review feedback suggest that reapplication is likely. It may also disappoint anyone expecting a pronounced plumping effect, as reviewers do not consistently report one. People who are sensitive to scented or flavored lip products should be aware of mixed scent and taste comments.

Beauty results

Gummy Bear delivers a glossy, light-reflective lip look with a sheer wash of warm light pink. Its strongest visible feature is shine rather than coverage: the finish can make lips look smoother and more polished while keeping the overall effect soft. The listing’s fuller-looking result is best understood as a subtle cosmetic appearance, not a dramatic change in lip volume.

Performance analysis

How it performs in practice

Each scoring dimension is separated into a compact card so the strengths and tradeoffs are easier to compare without reading one long block.

Effectiveness analysis

With an effectiveness score of 85/100, Maybelline Lifter Gloss performs strongly for its central purpose: adding comfortable-looking high shine with a sheer tint. The product listing highlights hyaluronic acid, a glossy finish, and an XL wand, while the review overview repeatedly praises smooth texture, hydration, and colour. Performance is less definitive for plumping and extended wear. Buyers can reasonably expect a polished gloss effect, but should not rely on it for a dramatic volume change or all-day shine.

Beauty results

The 88/100 beauty result score reflects a successful gloss-first look. Gummy Bear’s specified light, sheer warm-pink colour provides a subtle tint, while the 92/100 finish score indicates that high shine is the standout feature. Reviews commonly describe a healthy-looking, smooth, polished result. Those seeking bold pigment may find the understated payoff too soft, but it fits natural and layered lip looks well.

Skin compatibility

Skin compatibility scores 84/100, a favorable result for a lip-area makeup product. The listing identifies hyaluronic acid and describes the gloss as hydrating, while reviews generally report comfortable wear rather than irritation. However, full formula details were not supplied, and a minority of buyers mention scent or taste. Anyone with known sensitivity to lip cosmetics should check the current ingredient label and discontinue use if discomfort occurs.

Shade range

The 86/100 shade range score is supported by the stated availability of 20 hydrating lip makeup shades, including Gummy Bear and other modern options. Gummy Bear itself is a light, sheer, warm-leaning pink, so it favors a subtle result rather than strong colour coverage. Review feedback across shades suggests that several options are intentionally understated. Checking swatches on a range of skin tones is useful when selecting a more specific tint.

How it compares

Within the lip gloss category, this product appears stronger for reflective finish, comfortable texture, simple wand application, and mainstream buyer satisfaction than for extended wear. The 92/100 finish score and 90/100 comfort score make it particularly competitive for users who want a smooth, less sticky-looking gloss result. Its 20-shade offering also supports flexibility, though Gummy Bear itself remains deliberately sheer. By contrast, its 67/100 longevity score means it is less compelling for shoppers whose top priority is all-day colour or shine. The moderate claim-support score also makes it wiser to prioritize its gloss effect over its plumping positioning.

Ranking summary

With an overall score of 87/100, Maybelline Lifter Gloss Gummy Bear ranks as a strong option within the lip gloss category. Its profile is led by ease of use (93/100), finish quality (92/100), application (91/100), comfort (90/100), and customer satisfaction (91/100). The large 56,066-review base and 4.5/5 rating reinforce its appeal as an accessible high-shine gloss. Scores are less impressive for longevity at 67/100 and ethical transparency at 62/100, while claim support is moderate at 77/100 because plumping appears inconsistent. It is best ranked for glossy everyday makeup rather than long-wear or dramatic lip-volume expectations.

Buying advice

Consider Gummy Bear if you want a sheer, warm light-pink gloss that can be applied quickly and delivers noticeable high shine without the heavy feel some users associate with gloss. It is especially practical for everyday wear, layering, and frequent touch-ups. Skip it if you need opaque coverage, long wear, or a clearly visible plumping result. Before buying, confirm that the light, sheer shade suits your preferred level of colour and check the current ingredient label if you are sensitive to lip-product scent, taste, or specific cosmetic ingredients. Expect reapplication rather than all-day gloss.
87
Overall score

Final verdict

Maybelline Lifter Gloss in Gummy Bear is a strong drugstore lip gloss option, earning an 87/100 overall score through excellent shine, smooth application, comfortable wear, and unusually broad buyer approval. The sheer light-pink shade is a practical choice for soft everyday makeup and layering, while the XL wand makes touch-ups simple. Its main limitation is longevity: the high-shine effect may fade sooner than some buyers want. The fuller-looking claim should also be treated as subtle and variable. Choose it for a polished, hydrated-looking gloss finish, not for opaque colour or dramatic, long-lasting plumping.
Back to review

Key topics

Maybelline Lifter Gloss Gummy Bear review, Maybelline hydrating lip gloss, Gummy Bear sheer light pink gloss, hyaluronic acid lip gloss, high shine lip gloss review, Maybelline lip makeup, drugstore lip gloss

Frequently asked questions

Is Maybelline Lifter Gloss in Gummy Bear good for everyday makeup?
Gummy Bear appears well suited to everyday makeup if you prefer a sheer, light warm-pink tint rather than opaque colour. Its high-gloss finish, smooth application, and strong comfort score of 90/100 support easy, low-maintenance wear. Reviews also commonly describe the formula as comfortable and not overly sticky.
Does Maybelline Lifter Gloss provide a plumping effect?
The product listing describes a fuller-looking effect and enhanced lip contour, but the evidence is mixed. Some reviewers noticed a subtle fuller appearance, while others did not experience meaningful plumping. Its 77/100 claim-support score suggests treating the effect as a cosmetic, shine-and-hydration-led appearance rather than a dramatic result.
How long does Maybelline Lifter Gloss last?
Wear time is a relative weakness, with a longevity score of 67/100. Some buyers report decent staying power, but other feedback places the noticeable gloss effect at roughly an hour and notes the need for reapplication. Expect touch-ups, especially after eating, drinking, or when maintaining a high-shine finish matters.
Is Maybelline Lifter Gloss sticky?
The listing describes a non-sticky glossy finish, and this is broadly consistent with the supplied review overview. Multiple reviewers call the texture smooth, comfortable, and not too sticky, contributing to a 90/100 comfort score. Texture remains personal, but the available feedback is more favorable than critical on this point.
Is Gummy Bear a sheer or full-coverage lip gloss?
Gummy Bear is specified as a light-depth, sheer-intensity gloss with a warm undertone. Although the product specifications include both full and sheer coverage descriptors, the named shade data and product positioning point more clearly to a translucent wash of light pink paired with high shine than to full-coverage lip colour.
Is Maybelline Lifter Gloss easy to apply?
Yes, ease of use is one of its strongest areas at 93/100. The liquid gloss uses an XL wand that the brand says is designed to distribute product in one swipe, while the application score is also high at 91/100. This format should suit users who want quick, direct application without extra tools.
Does Maybelline Lifter Gloss have a noticeable scent or taste?
Scent is a less consistent area, reflected by a 74/100 scent score. Some reviewers reported no unpleasant smell or taste, while others mentioned subtle vanilla, coconut, or chocolate-like notes. Buyers sensitive to fragranced or flavored lip products should note that experiences differ and review the current product listing before purchasing.
Is Maybelline Lifter Gloss good value for money?
At the listed price of $9.98 for 0.18 ounces, the gloss earns an 85/100 value score. Its high shine, comfortable texture, easy application, wide shade offering, and very large review base strengthen the value case. The main trade-off is that its lower longevity may mean more frequent reapplication than longer-wearing lip products.

Related Guides & Rankings

L'Oreal Paris Colour Riche Mica Lipstick Review L'Oreal Paris Colour Riche Mica Lipstick Review e.l.f. Lip Plumping Gloss Pink Cosmo Review e.l.f. Lip Plumping Gloss Pink Cosmo Review NOONI Appleberry Lip Oil Review: Glossy Lip Stain NOONI Appleberry Lip Oil Review: Glossy Lip Stain Revlon ColorStay Overtime Lipcolor Review: Bare... Revlon ColorStay Overtime Lipcolor Review: Bare...