CosmeticRanker
Menu

Review

Maybelline Sky High Washable Mascara Review

Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High is a washable liquid mascara designed to lengthen, define and build lash volume. Its strongest evidence in this ranking is for a lightweight, visibly elongated everyday lash look, while maximum volume, flake resistance and removal can vary between users.
Expert reviewed
88
Overall score
Data-driven scoring Expert reviewed Updated analysis

Why we ranked it highly

Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Washable Mascara is a liquid eye makeup product in a tube, supplied here in Blackest Black. It is designed to provide defining, lengthening and volumizing effects with a buildable formula and high pigment density. The listing highlights a flexible Flex Tower brush that bends to coat lashes from root to tip, alongside a formula containing bamboo extract and fibers. This is primarily an everyday mascara for people seeking longer, more separated-looking lashes without choosing a water-resistant format. The brand states that it is allergy tested and ophthalmologist tested, and lists it as suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. With multiple listed colour options, it can also suit users who prefer brown or more expressive mascara shades alongside classic black.
90-day review Expert reviewed User feedback Data scoring

Key specs

Features & Specs

Product Benefits
Defining, Lengthening, Volumizing, Washable
Other Special Features of the Product
High Pigment Density
Item Form
Liquid
Specialty
natural
Container Type
Tube
Water Resistance Level
Not Water Resistant
Mascara Wand Type
Straight
Skin Type
Sensitive
Skin Tone
All
Coverage
Full

Item details

Product Benefits
Defining, Lengthening, Volumizing, Washable
Brand Name
MAYBELLINE
Item Form
Liquid
Number of Items
1
Container Type
Tube
Package Type Name
Tube
UPC
041554590517
Manufacturer
Maybelline New York
Global Trade Identification Number
00041554590517
Manufacturer Part Number
041554590517
Model Number
041554590517
Skin Type
Sensitive
Item Weight
18.14 g
Skin Tone
All

Product details

Product Dimensions
0.85 x 2.75 x 5.63 inches; 0.64 ounces
Item model number
041554590517
UPC
041554590517
Manufacturer
Maybelline New York

Scores breakdown

90 /100

Effectiveness

89 /100

Beauty results

84 /100

Skin compatibility

82 /100

Hair compatibility

78 /100

Shade range

86 /100

Finish quality

80 /100

Longevity

72 /100

Ingredient quality

Strengths

  • High effectiveness score of 90, led by lengthening and defining performance.
  • Strong visible-result score of 89 for a lifted, separated lash look.
  • Flexible Flex Tower brush is designed to reach lashes from root to tip.
  • Washable liquid formula is positioned for lightweight everyday wear.
  • Available in several black, brown and colourful shades.
  • Excellent customer satisfaction score of 92 across 182,509 reviews.
  • Competitive value score of 89 at the listed price of $8.08.

Limitations

  • Volume may feel too moderate for buyers seeking a very thick, dramatic false-lash effect.
  • Review feedback is mixed on clumping, flaking and removal, especially as the tube ages.
  • The formula is listed as not water resistant.
  • Some users report minor under-eye smudging after long wear.
  • Ingredient-quality evidence is limited beyond the stated bamboo extract and fibers.
  • No ethical or sustainability details were provided.

Ideal user profiles

  • Everyday mascara wearers who prioritise visible length and definition.
  • Buyers wanting a lightweight washable formula rather than a waterproof mascara.
  • People with sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers who value the stated testing information.
  • Users who prefer a defined, lifted lash result over maximum thickness.
  • Shoppers looking for a lower-priced mascara with substantial buyer feedback.

Use cases

  • Daily makeup routines that call for lengthened, separated lashes.
  • Natural-glam eye looks with buildable definition.
  • Quick mascara application using a flexible, narrow brush format.
  • Brown, black or colourful mascara looks, depending on the selected shade.
  • Contact-lens-wearing makeup routines, subject to individual comfort.
  • Washable makeup looks where easy end-of-day removal is preferred.

Fit and positioning

Who this works for

Category positioning

This product sits in the makeup category, specifically as a washable lengthening and defining mascara. Its role is to add visible emphasis to lashes as part of an eye makeup routine, with buildable coats intended to increase impact. The supplied ranking data positions it more strongly as an accessible daily-wear mascara for length, separation and lift than as a specialised waterproof or maximum-volume formula.

Best for

Sky High is best suited to shoppers who want noticeable lash length, definition and a lightweight feel at a lower price point. Its 90 effectiveness score, 88 ease-of-use score and 92 customer satisfaction score support its appeal for routine makeup use. It may be particularly relevant to users seeking a washable formula, a flexible brush for smaller lashes, or the listed sensitive-eye and contact-lens-wearer positioning.

Not best for

This mascara may be less suitable for buyers whose priority is an intensely thick, false-lash-style volume result, since review feedback suggests its volume can be more moderate. It is also not the clearest choice for people who require water-resistant makeup, as it is explicitly listed as not water resistant. Mixed reports of flaking, clumping, smudging and removal mean highly wear-sensitive users should approach expectations carefully.

Beauty results

The main visible result is a longer, more defined and lifted lash appearance. Reviews frequently describe noticeable length, separation and a lightweight finish, while the buildable format allows users to adjust intensity. The result appears more polished and elongating than heavily thickened, especially for those seeking an everyday natural-glam eye look.

Performance analysis

How it performs in practice

Each scoring dimension is separated into a compact card so the strengths and tradeoffs are easier to compare without reading one long block.

Effectiveness analysis

With an effectiveness score of 90, Maybelline Sky High performs strongly for its central purpose: making lashes look longer and more defined. The supplied description attributes this to a flexible brush and a fiber-containing formula, and reviewers commonly report visible length with good coverage. Volume is present but appears less reliable as the headline result; one detailed review found it suitable for a lifted look but not especially bold thickness. Reports on flaking and clumping are mixed, so wear performance is not identical for every user.

Beauty results

The beauty result score of 89 reflects a strong cosmetic payoff centred on elongation, separation and lift. Users describe lashes as longer and defined, with some reporting curl hold and a lightweight feel rather than stiff, heavy-looking coating. The finish seems especially suitable for polished everyday makeup. Those seeking the densest possible lash line may find the final effect more refined than dramatic.

Skin compatibility

The skin compatibility score of 84 is favourable for an eye-area makeup product. Maybelline states that the formula is allergy tested and ophthalmologist tested, and that it is suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. These are useful listing details, but individual tolerance still differs. The provided data does not include a complete ingredient list or detailed sensitivity-focused review evidence, so it cannot confirm universal compatibility.

Shade range

The shade range score of 78 indicates a useful, though not exceptional, set of options. Beyond Very Black, Blackest Black and Cosmic Black, the supplied listing includes True Brown, Blue Mist, Burgundy Haze, Space Diamond, Plum Twilight and Green Altitude. This gives users alternatives for softer or colour-led eye looks. The data does not provide undertone information, swatches or broad shade-match feedback, so colour accuracy cannot be assessed here.

How it compares

Within the washable mascara category, Sky High appears stronger for lengthening, definition, price-to-performance and broad customer approval than for the most dramatic volume effect. Its 90 effectiveness score and 89 beauty-result score indicate a notably capable everyday formula, while its 89 value score makes it accessible at the listed price. The flexible brush and broad colour selection add practical appeal. In comparison with products designed around water resistance or high-impact thickness, its not-water-resistant specification and mixed wear feedback are important trade-offs. Ingredient information and long-term formula stability are comparatively less well supported in the provided data.

Ranking summary

With an overall score of 88, Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High ranks as a very strong washable mascara option. Its profile is led by effectiveness at 90, beauty results at 89, value at 89 and customer satisfaction at 92, making lengthening and definition its clearest advantages. Ease of use, comfort and application also score well, supporting its everyday-makeup positioning. The ranking is held back by more moderate ingredient quality at 72 and durability at 73, alongside mixed customer reports about clumping, flaking and removal. It is strongest for buyers who prioritise defined length over maximum thickness or water-resistant wear.

Buying advice

Consider Maybelline Sky High if you want a washable mascara focused on longer, more defined lashes, especially if you value a lightweight feel and a budget-friendly price. It is also worth considering for contact lens wearers or sensitive-eye shoppers who are comfortable relying on the manufacturer's stated testing information. Choose a shade carefully, as the range extends beyond Blackest Black. Skip it if you specifically need water resistance or expect intense, thick volume from one product. Because reviews differ on clumping, flaking and removal, apply in controlled layers and check the current ingredient list if you have ingredient sensitivities.
88
Overall score

Final verdict

Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Washable Mascara is a strong option in the everyday mascara category, earning an overall score of 88. Its key strength is a consistently well-supported lengthening and defining result, reinforced by high customer satisfaction and strong value at the listed price. The flexible brush, washable format and varied shade selection further support its practical appeal. Its main limitation is that volume, flake resistance and removal are not equally consistent for every user, and it is not water resistant. It is best for shoppers who want a lifted, separated lash look rather than the boldest possible volume.
Back to review

Key topics

Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High mascara review, Sky High Washable Mascara, Maybelline lengthening mascara, Blackest Black mascara, volumizing washable mascara, drugstore mascara review, mascara for sensitive eyes, buildable mascara

Frequently asked questions

Is Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Washable Mascara good for lengthening?
Based on its 90 effectiveness score and 89 beauty-result score, this mascara appears particularly strong for lengthening and definition. Reviewers repeatedly mention visibly longer lashes, including with one or few coats. The flexible brush is designed to extend lashes from root to tip, though individual results can vary with application technique and lash type.
Does Sky High Washable Mascara provide dramatic volume?
It is marketed as volumizing, and some reviewers report fuller-looking lashes. However, the supplied review summary and score interpretation suggest volume is less consistent than lengthening. It is likely a better fit for a defined, lifted everyday result than for shoppers who want the thickest possible, high-drama lash effect from mascara alone.
Is Maybelline Sky High Mascara suitable for sensitive eyes?
The product listing states that it is allergy tested, ophthalmologist tested, and suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. Its skin compatibility score is 84. These details do not guarantee comfort for every person, so users with known sensitivities should review the product information and stop use if discomfort occurs.
How long does Maybelline Sky High Washable Mascara last?
Its longevity score is 80, indicating solid but not flawless wear. Several reviews describe all-day performance without flaking, while others report flaking or slight smudging during extended wear. One reviewer also noted that performance may decline as the product ages, so results can depend on the condition of the tube and wear conditions.
Is Sky High Washable Mascara easy to remove?
The listing describes this as a washable mascara that removes easily, and some reviewers found removal straightforward with water or eye makeup remover. Feedback is mixed, however: other buyers found it harder to remove. Since it is not listed as water resistant, it may suit those who prefer washable formulas, but removal experiences are not uniform.
What shades are available in Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara?
The provided listing names Very Black, Blackest Black, Cosmic Black, True Brown, Blue Mist, Burgundy Haze, Space Diamond, Plum Twilight and Green Altitude. The shade-range score is 78, reflecting useful variety beyond standard black, although availability may differ by retailer, region, and individual product listing.
Is Maybelline Sky High Mascara good value?
With a value score of 89, a listed price of $8.08, and 4.5 out of 5 stars from 182,509 reviews, it presents a strong value case in the supplied ranking data. The strongest reasons are its lengthening performance and broad buyer satisfaction, although mixed feedback on wear and tube longevity remains worth considering.
Are the claims for Maybelline Sky High Mascara well supported?
The claim support score is 86. The supplied specifications support a washable, lengthening, defining and volumizing mascara format, while many reviews align with noticeable length and definition. Claims about no flaking or smudging have less consistent support because buyer feedback is mixed. Listing claims and customer experiences should not be treated as clinical evidence.

Related Guides & Rankings

L’Oreal Voluminous Original Waterproof Mascara... L’Oreal Voluminous Original Waterproof Mascara... Maybelline The Falsies Lash Lift Mascara Review Maybelline The Falsies Lash Lift Mascara Review PrimeLash Brown Mascara Review for Mature Lashes PrimeLash Brown Mascara Review for Mature Lashes Maybelline Falsies Mascara Review: Blackest Black Maybelline Falsies Mascara Review: Blackest Black